Tough choices....

[The Black Tot]

To return to the beginning question, I would choose two of the Berry's.

My favorites so far have been two of the ones not mentioned on your list, the Guadeloupe and the Nicaraguan.

The only one of these that we tasted and didn't want was the Fidjian, which was a bit metallic for our tastes.

[Who-is-this-Ron-guy?]

Thanks BT. I would have went with the BB&R bottles in the end, but a total let down from Total Wine! The staff there were pleasant, but they do not ship spirits (something I was not aware of). Alas.

I managed to source a few bottles of Samaroli instead.